View of Swan Range
Stoltze/DNRC to Log Jewel Basin Area Trails!

UPDATE 2/21/15:

The Crater Notch Trail has been trashed by logging and not repaired!

Click here for more photos and a concise alert because YOUR EMAILS ARE NEEDED NOW to get the trail repaired and insure bare-ground logging is not allowed!

UPDATE 12/24/14:

DNRC issued its decision to indeed log along the lower reaches of the Broken Leg and Crater Notch trails, adding a decision (page 11) and responses to public comments at the end of its Environmental Assessment.

While we didn't succeed in stopping this logging, we won several major concessions that will help protect the trails:

1. Huge, heavy feller-buncher machines will not be used to cut the "diseased" trees. They will be hand-felled using chain saws, greatly reducing machine traffic on the ground.

2. Skidding of the logs will be done using cable-winch skidders, rather than grapple/tong skidders - and it will be done on frozen ground and snow. The greater "reach" of the cables will greatly reduce the soil area traveled on by the skidders and frozen ground will lessen damage to the soil and trails.

3. DNRC will mark the trees to be cut, rather than leaving the choice up to Stoltze Lumber.

4. Public comments from 50 people let DNRC know there are lots of eyes on this project and should help insure a more careful job is done.

We took lots of "before" photos of the trails and we will take "during" and "after" photos as well in order to document whether DNRC and Stoltze followed through on the promises made.

Big thanks to all of you that wrote in on this. The results will be better for it!

UPDATE 12/15/14:

THE GOOD NEWS: Fifty folks like you told DNRC to protect the Broken Leg and Crater Notch Trails, including the nearby aesthetics and wildlife habitat - and DNRC has halved the acreage it proposes to let Stoltze Lumber Company log there.

THE BAD NEWS: Rather than likewise reduce the "salvage" logging volume from the initial proposal of 55 truck loads, DNRC has proposed to now log some green trees along with the dead and dying trees in order to "sanitize" the forest (by removing up to 50% of the trees)!

DNRC has posted a brief Environmental Assessment and has invited public comment again until December 19, 2014.

We urge you to email DNRC's Nick Aschenwald today (naschenwald@mt.gov) and let him know DNRC's trickery is not appreciated: halving the logging area while increasing the logging per acre is insincere and is not going to protect these trails!

Urge DNRC to select the "No Action" alternative in the EA, which would simply leave the area alone and natural.

Click here to read SVC's comments to DNRC on its EA.

Many thanks to those of you that are writing in on this!

(From October 5, 2014, below).

Your email message is needed today to keep F.H. Stoltze and DNRC from logging the Broken Leg and Crater Notch Trails that access the Jewel Basin Hiking Area!

While logging its neighboring land near the Jewel Basin Road this fall and winter, Stoltze wants to take feller-bunchers and grapple skidders onto Montana Department of Natural Resources and Conservation land to "salvage" 55 log truck loads of reportedly dead and dying trees.

DNRC says this beautiful, healthy forest may be reduced to as little as 8-10 trees per acre!

Please email DNRC's Nick Aschenwald today (naschenwald@mt.gov) and tell him you want the public trees on State Land left for wildlife and people while Stoltze saws its trees into boards!

DNRC in 2006 agreed to protect the recreational and aesthetic values of these trails by moving its Foothills Timber Sale downhill and out of sight of them. Click here to read that letter of agreement!

The Forest Service's Broken Leg and Crater Notch Trails lie on DNRC easements in the exact area Stoltze wants to log and are highly valued, non-motorized recreation trails leading to Jewel Basin and the historic Alpine Trail #7. This is simply the wrong choice of an area to be logged!

The Broken Leg Trail has already been turned into a logging road where it crosses Stoltze Land. Let's convince DNRC to again respect the value of these trails where they cross State Land and not allow logging there!

Click here for a map of the proposed logging.

Comments are due by October 20th!

Click here for our recent letter to the editor for more information.

Click here and scroll down to "Scoping Notices - Birch Creek" for DNRC's invite of public comment.

UPDATE: Click here for SVC's letter to DNRC in this matter.

This article published on October 05, 2014 • [Permalink]


Logging Road Landslide
Logging road landslide into Sullivan Creek bull trout habitat! Keith Hammer photo.

What's New
Oppose the 1000-person-per-hour Tram Proposed for Columbia Mountain! October 03, 2026

The giant Pursuit corporation is asking the Flathead National Forest to permit its building of a 1000-person-per-hour tram on your public land from Hungry Horse to a high ridge on Columbia Mountain! Tell the Forest Supervisor today to dismiss this proposal outright, as his predecessor did with a more limited proposal in 2023!

Summer Newsletter: Apocalypse Now - The Trump Version! September 08, 2026

Our Summer newsletter reports on Trump's broad-scale attack on the environment, what we are doing about it, and what you can do to help!

Lawsuit Filed Against Trump's Trashing of Endangered Species Habitats! July 15, 2026

Swan View Coalition has joined a lawsuit opposing the Trump administration's attempt to repeal protection of threatened and endangered species habitat!

Winter-Spring Newsletter: The Empire Strikes Back and So Do We! June 09, 2026

Our Winter-Spring newsletter reports on Trump administration efforts to convince you the only healthy forest is a logged forest and how we are fighting back with lawsuits like the one we just filed against the West Reservoir logging and road building project! 

Groups File Lawsuit Against West Reservoir Logging Project! June 05, 2026

Swan View Coalition and Friends of the Wild Swan on June 5 filed a lawsuit against the federal government for approving the Flathead National Forest's West Reservoir logging and road building project without completing interagency consultation required under the Endangered Species Act.

Your Comments Needed Now to Prevent 5-Fold Expansion of Holland Lake Lodge Sewer! March 24, 2026

Your comments are needed today to prevent the 5-fold expansion of the private Holland Lake Lodge sewer at public expense!

Your Comments Needed Now on Draft Flathead River Plan! February 26, 2026

Your comments are needed now to stop the commercial overcrowding of the Flathead's Wild and Scenic Rivers!

Your Comments Needed Now on Massive Logging and Burning Project! January 06, 2026

Your comments are needed by January 15 on a 68,000 acre logging and burning project along the Middle Fork Flathead River, including the Wild and Scenic River corridor, roadless lands, and proposed Wilderness areas!

Holidays Newsletter: Staying the Course in 2025! December 09, 2025

Our Holidays Newsletter reports on 2025 accomplishments, how our members have helped accomplish them, the joy and beauty of our Swan Ranger reports, and how you can oppose Trump's gutting of the Endangered Species Act in a matter of minutes!

Fall Newsletter: Staying Positive in Negative Times! October 23, 2025

Our Fall Newsletter reports on the Forest Service turned politically partisan, Big Tech gobbling up public resources, progress on road closure monitoring, how we can turn lemon impediments into lemonade, and our upcoming membership meeting November 16!

Summer Newsletter: Citizen Oversight and Sound Public Policy a Must! September 03, 2025

Our Summer Newsletter reports on two citizen oversight victories, asks you to comment on Trump's plan to rescind roadless land protections by Sept 19, and announces Keith Hammer has been given FWN's 2025 “Activist of the Year Award!”

Your Comments to DNRC Made a Difference and We Need Them Again! June 09, 2025

Your comments convinced DNRC to save this hemlock forest in Krause Basin. We need to hold DNRC to its new promise that it won't log hemlock forests south of Krause Basin either!

Winter-Spring Newsletter: Shutting the Public Out of Public Lands Management! May 30, 2025

Our Winter-Spring Newsletter describes how the Trump administration is ordering a 25% increase in Forest Service logging and furthering the agency's efforts to shut the public and the courts out of the public land management process!

Your Comments Needed BY MAY 14 on Holland Lake Lodge 20-Year Permit! April 28, 2025

Your comments are needed BY MAY 14 as the Forest Service attempts to grant new owners of Holland Lake Lodge a 20-year permit to occupy public lands - without first revealing what they intend to do there!

Your Comments Needed on East Valley Logging Project! March 17, 2025

Your comments are needed by April 6 on a logging project proposed all along the Swan Range from Columbia Falls to Swan Lake!

Your Comments Needed on Flathead River Plan! January 30, 2025

Your comments are needed today to stop the commercial overcrowding of the Flathead's Wild and Scenic Rivers!

Swan View Report Shows Forest Service Slow to Fix Ineffective Road Closures! December 24, 2024

Swan View Coalition has issued a new report showing the Forest Service is slow and inept at repairing its ineffective road closures and is grossly underreporting the percentage of its closures that are likely ineffective!

Holidays Newsletter: Giving Thanks in 2024 but Looking Hard at 2025! November 19, 2024

Our Holidays Newsletter gives thanks for what we've accomplished in 2024, but looks hard at the challenges posed in 2025!

Fall Newsletter: Krause Basin Update and Annual Meeting! October 21, 2024

Our Fall newsletter provides a quick update on activities in Krause Basin, announces our annual membership meeting, and offers you the last chance to have your donation doubled by Cinnabar Foundation!

Summer Newsletter: Back to the Future with Two Big Wins! July 31, 2024

Our Summer newsletter details two recent victories on the Flathead National Forest for wildlife, in court and on-the-ground!